Hard water and your water heater
Updated November 20, 2026 · Based on EPA and other public sources listed below · How we make our content
Short answer: heating hard water makes calcium carbonate scale settle in the tank and on heating elements. Scale insulates the heat source, so the heater burns more energy, gets noisy and can wear out sooner. Above about 7 grains per gallon (120 mg/L), flush a tank heater at least yearly, descale tankless units on the manufacturer's schedule, or soften the water.
How hard water creates scale in a water heater
Hard water carries dissolved calcium and magnesium. When it is heated, part of the calcium comes out of solution as calcium carbonate, the white crust you see in kettles. In a tank heater it settles on the bottom and coats electric elements. In a tankless heater it lines the narrow passages of the heat exchanger. The harder the water and the hotter the setting, the faster scale builds up.
Scale is a poor conductor of heat. With a layer of scale between the burner or element and the water, more energy goes in for the same amount of hot water, and the parts that touch the scale run hotter than designed.
What testing found
The best-known test is a 2010 study by Battelle, funded by the water treatment industry's research foundation. It ran gas storage, electric storage and tankless gas water heaters side by side on hard and softened water under accelerated conditions. As summarised by the industry and trade press:
- Gas tank heaters on hard water lost efficiency (from about 70% to about 67% after the equivalent of two years) and collected far more scale than those on softened water.
- Tankless heaters on very hard water (26 grains per gallon) stopped working because scale blocked the plumbing after the equivalent of about 1.6 years.
- Electric heaters mainly showed a durability effect: scale makes the heating element run hotter, which shortens its life.
- Low-flow showerheads on hard water lost much of their flow within about 18 months.
Because the study was industry-funded and used accelerated, very hard water, treat the exact numbers as an illustration of the direction and size of the effect rather than a prediction for your home.
Tap water hardness in major US cities
Where your water heater falls depends on your local water. These cities publish the hardness of their tap water:
| City | Hardness | Class | Water heater upkeep |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York, NY | 31 mg/L · 1.8 gpg | Soft | Scale is rarely a problem |
| Los Angeles, CA | 170 mg/L · 9.9 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Chicago, IL | 135 mg/L · 7.9 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Phoenix, AZ | 218 mg/L · 12.7 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Philadelphia, PA | 125 mg/L · 7.3 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| San Antonio, TX | 300 mg/L · 17.5 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| San Diego, CA | 276 mg/L · 16.1 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Dallas, TX | 138 mg/L · 8.1 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Jacksonville, FL | 246 mg/L · 14.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Austin, TX | 93 mg/L · 5.4 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Fort Worth, TX | 128 mg/L · 7.5 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Columbus, OH | 115 mg/L · 6.7 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Charlotte, NC | 39 mg/L · 2.3 gpg | Soft | Scale is rarely a problem |
| Indianapolis, IN | 292 mg/L · 17.1 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| San Francisco, CA | 8 mg/L · 0.5 gpg | Soft | Scale is rarely a problem |
| Seattle, WA | 28 mg/L · 1.6 gpg | Soft | Scale is rarely a problem |
| Denver, CO | 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Las Vegas, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Boston, MA | 16 mg/L · 0.9 gpg | Soft | Scale is rarely a problem |
| Detroit, MI | 116 mg/L · 6.8 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Louisville/Jefferson County metro government, KY | 135 mg/L · 7.9 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Milwaukee, WI | 138 mg/L · 8.1 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Kansas City, MO | 100 mg/L · 5.8 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Aurora, CO | 136 mg/L · 7.9 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| New Orleans, LA | 101 mg/L · 5.9 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Cleveland, OH | 117 mg/L · 6.8 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Henderson, NV | 304 mg/L · 17.8 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Lubbock, TX | 192 mg/L · 11.2 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Paradise, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Sioux Falls, SD | 250 mg/L · 14.6 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Amarillo, TX | 238 mg/L · 13.9 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Oxnard, CA | 319 mg/L · 18.6 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Sunrise Manor, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Spring Valley, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Corona, CA | 146 mg/L · 8.5 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Syracuse, NY | 127 mg/L · 7.4 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Metairie, LA | 78 mg/L · 4.6 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Warren, MI | 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| West Valley City, UT | 176 mg/L · 10.3 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Simi Valley, CA | 140 mg/L · 8.2 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Thousand Oaks, CA | 140 mg/L · 8.2 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Vallejo, CA | 153 mg/L · 8.9 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| Concord, CA | 74 mg/L · 4.3 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Independence, MO | 123 mg/L · 7.2 gpg | Hard | Flush yearly; consider a softener |
| West Jordan, UT | 183 mg/L · 10.7 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Richmond, CA | 68 mg/L · 4 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Carlsbad, CA | 230 mg/L · 13.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Santa Maria, CA | 315 mg/L · 18.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Enterprise, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Centennial, CO | 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Dearborn, MI | 102 mg/L · 6 gpg | Moderately hard | Flush yearly |
| Yuma, AZ | 345 mg/L · 20.2 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Whitney, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
| Winchester, NV | 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg | Very hard | Flush at least yearly; softener common |
Tap water hardness as published by each city's water utility. For any other town, look it up on the map.
Maintenance schedule by water hardness
| Your water | Tank water heater | Tankless water heater |
|---|---|---|
| Soft (under 3.5 gpg / 60 mg/L) | Drain a few gallons and check the anode rod per the manual | Descale per the manual; scale is rarely a problem |
| Moderately hard (3.5–7 gpg) | Flush yearly | Descale per the manual |
| Hard (7–10.5 gpg) | Flush about every six months; check anode rod yearly | Descale about every six months |
| Very hard (over 10.5 gpg / 180 mg/L) | Flush about every six months or soften the water | Descale about every six months and consider softening or a scale-prevention device the manufacturer approves |
Rheem, one of the largest water heater makers, recommends maintenance at least once a year and, in hard-water areas, flushing or descaling about every six months, plus an annual anode rod check. Always follow your own owner's manual first: warranties often require specific maintenance, and some exclude damage from scale.
How to flush a tank water heater
- Turn the heater off: gas to "pilot" or "vacation", or switch off the breaker for an electric heater.
- Let the water cool, or take care: it can scald.
- Attach a hose to the drain valve at the bottom and run it to a floor drain or outside.
- Open a hot water tap in the house, then open the drain valve and let the tank drain until the water runs clear.
- Close the valve, refill the tank with the hot tap open until water flows steadily, then turn the heater back on.
Should you soften the water?
A softener removes the calcium and magnesium before they reach the heater, so scale doesn't form. It also adds a little sodium to the water and uses water and salt to regenerate. See do you need a water softener for a quick way to decide and size one, or salt-free vs salt-based softeners if salt is a concern. Tankless owners should also read tankless water heaters and hard water. Hot water smells like rotten eggs? See the water heater fix.
How many years to expect from a tank or tankless heater: how long does a water heater last?
Frequently asked questions
Does hard water damage a water heater?
Hard water doesn't damage the tank directly, but heating it makes calcium carbonate scale settle on the bottom of the tank and on heating elements. Scale insulates the burner or element from the water, so the heater uses more energy, gets noisier and can fail sooner.
How often should I flush my water heater if I have hard water?
At least once a year, and about every six months in hard-water areas, according to Rheem's maintenance guidance. Follow your owner's manual, which may set a schedule for your model.
Why does my water heater make a popping or rumbling noise?
A common cause is sediment and scale on the bottom of a gas tank: water trapped under the layer boils and pops when the burner runs. Flushing the tank often reduces the noise.
Will a water softener protect my water heater?
Softened water does not form calcium carbonate scale. In an industry-funded laboratory study, heaters on softened water kept their efficiency while heaters on hard water lost efficiency and built up scale. Softened water can wear the anode rod faster, so check the rod regularly.
Sources
- Water Quality Association: Softened water benefits studies (Battelle, 2010)
- Contractor: Battelle finds water softeners aid energy efficiency and appliance life
- Rheem: How to keep tank and tankless water heaters running at peak performance
- University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension: Drinking water treatment, water softening (G1491)