Whole-house vs under-sink water filters
Updated November 21, 2026 · Based on EPA and other public sources listed below · How we make our content
Short answer: for contaminants that only matter when you drink the water, such as lead, arsenic, nitrate or PFAS, an under-sink (point-of-use) filter on the drinking tap is usually enough. Choose a whole-house (point-of-entry) system when the problem also comes through the air or skin (radon, volatile chemicals) or affects all plumbing (hard water, iron).
Whole-house vs under-sink: the difference
| Under-sink (point of use) | Whole-house (point of entry) | |
|---|---|---|
| Treats | Only drinking and cooking water, usually one tap | All water entering the home |
| Typical setup | Under the kitchen sink with its own faucet, so washing water stays untreated | Where the water line enters the house |
| Fits problems from | Drinking the water | Drinking, showering (breathing, skin) and plumbing |
| Examples | Reverse osmosis, carbon, activated alumina | Water softener, whole-house carbon, iron filters, radon treatment |
EPA explains that under-sink units with a separate faucet let you use untreated water for washing and cleaning, which keeps operating costs down.
Which one for your problem
| Problem | Usually enough | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Arsenic, lead, copper, fluoride, uranium | Under-sink reverse osmosis | EPA lists RO as a small-system option for all of these; they matter when swallowed |
| PFAS | Under-sink carbon or RO | EPA found both can cut PFAS below detection; whole-house versions need much more equipment |
| Nitrate | Under-sink RO or distillation | A drinking-water concern |
| Radon, volatile organic chemicals (VOCs) | Whole-house | EPA: they become airborne at untreated taps such as showerheads |
| Hard water | Whole-house softener | Scale forms in every pipe, fixture and water heater |
| Iron, manganese, sulfur smell | Whole-house | Stains and smell affect all taps |
| Chlorine taste | Under-sink or pitcher carbon | A taste issue at the drinking tap |
Whole-house filters for PFAS: what EPA found
EPA researchers tested carbon (GAC) and reverse osmosis systems both at the tap and for the whole house. Both reduced PFAS below laboratory detection limits. But a whole-house RO system would need extra parts, such as a 200–500 gallon storage tank and a 20-gallon bladder tank, regular membrane and filter changes, and possibly mineralization cartridges to prevent lead and copper corrosion in household plumbing. Whole-house carbon needs large amounts of carbon to work. EPA recommends a device certified by an independent party (for PFAS, NSF P473) and proper maintenance.
Before you buy
- Test or look up your water first. EPA says a complete analysis of your water is needed to choose the right device. City water: check your town's hardness, PFAS, lead and violation records and your water quality report. Wells: test the well.
- Check certification for the specific contaminant you want removed.
- Plan for maintenance: filters and membranes must be replaced, and EPA advises testing treated water to confirm the device works.
More on one whole-house problem: radon in well water.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a whole-house filter and an under-sink filter?
A whole-house (point-of-entry) system treats all water entering the home. An under-sink (point-of-use) system treats only the water used for drinking and cooking, usually at one tap, often with its own faucet.
Do I need a whole-house filter for lead or arsenic?
Usually not. EPA notes that contaminants such as arsenic and fluoride are a concern when swallowed, so treating only drinking and cooking water can be enough; EPA lists reverse osmosis as a small-system option for arsenic, lead, copper, fluoride, radium and uranium.
When is a whole-house system needed?
When the problem is breathing in or skin contact, not just drinking. EPA says point-of-entry devices should be used when skin absorption or inhalation is a concern, as with radon and volatile organic chemicals released at showerheads. Hardness is also treated for the whole house with a softener.
Is whole-house reverse osmosis a good idea for PFAS?
EPA found both carbon and reverse osmosis can reduce PFAS below detection limits, but a whole-house RO system needs extra parts such as a 200–500 gallon storage tank and may need remineralization to prevent lead and copper corrosion in household plumbing.