Whole-house vs under-sink water filters

Updated November 21, 2026 · Based on EPA and other public sources listed below · How we make our content

Short answer: for contaminants that only matter when you drink the water, such as lead, arsenic, nitrate or PFAS, an under-sink (point-of-use) filter on the drinking tap is usually enough. Choose a whole-house (point-of-entry) system when the problem also comes through the air or skin (radon, volatile chemicals) or affects all plumbing (hard water, iron).

Whole-house vs under-sink: the difference

Under-sink (point of use)Whole-house (point of entry)
TreatsOnly drinking and cooking water, usually one tapAll water entering the home
Typical setupUnder the kitchen sink with its own faucet, so washing water stays untreatedWhere the water line enters the house
Fits problems fromDrinking the waterDrinking, showering (breathing, skin) and plumbing
ExamplesReverse osmosis, carbon, activated aluminaWater softener, whole-house carbon, iron filters, radon treatment

EPA explains that under-sink units with a separate faucet let you use untreated water for washing and cleaning, which keeps operating costs down.

Which one for your problem

ProblemUsually enoughWhy
Arsenic, lead, copper, fluoride, uraniumUnder-sink reverse osmosisEPA lists RO as a small-system option for all of these; they matter when swallowed
PFASUnder-sink carbon or ROEPA found both can cut PFAS below detection; whole-house versions need much more equipment
NitrateUnder-sink RO or distillationA drinking-water concern
Radon, volatile organic chemicals (VOCs)Whole-houseEPA: they become airborne at untreated taps such as showerheads
Hard waterWhole-house softenerScale forms in every pipe, fixture and water heater
Iron, manganese, sulfur smellWhole-houseStains and smell affect all taps
Chlorine tasteUnder-sink or pitcher carbonA taste issue at the drinking tap

Whole-house filters for PFAS: what EPA found

EPA researchers tested carbon (GAC) and reverse osmosis systems both at the tap and for the whole house. Both reduced PFAS below laboratory detection limits. But a whole-house RO system would need extra parts, such as a 200–500 gallon storage tank and a 20-gallon bladder tank, regular membrane and filter changes, and possibly mineralization cartridges to prevent lead and copper corrosion in household plumbing. Whole-house carbon needs large amounts of carbon to work. EPA recommends a device certified by an independent party (for PFAS, NSF P473) and proper maintenance.

Before you buy

  • Test or look up your water first. EPA says a complete analysis of your water is needed to choose the right device. City water: check your town's hardness, PFAS, lead and violation records and your water quality report. Wells: test the well.
  • Check certification for the specific contaminant you want removed.
  • Plan for maintenance: filters and membranes must be replaced, and EPA advises testing treated water to confirm the device works.

More on one whole-house problem: radon in well water.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a whole-house filter and an under-sink filter?

A whole-house (point-of-entry) system treats all water entering the home. An under-sink (point-of-use) system treats only the water used for drinking and cooking, usually at one tap, often with its own faucet.

Do I need a whole-house filter for lead or arsenic?

Usually not. EPA notes that contaminants such as arsenic and fluoride are a concern when swallowed, so treating only drinking and cooking water can be enough; EPA lists reverse osmosis as a small-system option for arsenic, lead, copper, fluoride, radium and uranium.

When is a whole-house system needed?

When the problem is breathing in or skin contact, not just drinking. EPA says point-of-entry devices should be used when skin absorption or inhalation is a concern, as with radon and volatile organic chemicals released at showerheads. Hardness is also treated for the whole house with a softener.

Is whole-house reverse osmosis a good idea for PFAS?

EPA found both carbon and reverse osmosis can reduce PFAS below detection limits, but a whole-house RO system needs extra parts such as a 200–500 gallon storage tank and may need remineralization to prevent lead and copper corrosion in household plumbing.

Sources

Related guides